Sunday, 13 September 2015

Leading Inquiry at a Teacher Level: It's all about mentorship.

Leading inquiry at a teacher level: it's all about mentorship (Mike Fowler, 2012) strongly backs up lots of my thoughts about teaching as inquiry being successful when lead properly (with research).

His article is from his personal experience in a secondary school setting, but the ideas can be applied to any setting. He talks about using middle leaders to help support the teaching as inquiry in secondary schools, because they are the ones who have the most day to day interactions with teachers. As I read the article I tended to just read 'leaders' when he wrote 'middle leaders', for the purpose of my schools.

One point he makes very early on is " leaders in schools have a critical role in mentoring teachers as they work with the teaching as inquiry process. One-to-one interactions and professional conversations with each teacher largely determine the quality of inquiry..." This is not surprising. 100% of my schools confirm this. In my target school I have worked with the Principal to establish inquiries and to reflect on them. I do however feel as though I am still driving the bus, not the Principal. I don't think much is talked about when I am not there. This is an area I know I need to work on and have discussed earlier (the fact that I was a scale A teacher 9 months ago, trying to support Principals in areas I have no experience in!) However, In my research recently I feel as though I am getting more evidence to back up my thoughts. The fact the ERO recommended in 2011 that all schools should be using Teaching as Inquiry to help create strong self review practice, gives the topic some weight. It is also worth noting, that one of my other schools, (who is not my target school) has made amazing progress in this area and the Principal is really taking charge of it. This is in part due to their last ERO visit (earlier this year) where one of their recommendations was to implement T@I and to use as part of the appraisal process. The way I see it though, a win is a win, however they get there!

Another excellent point that Mike makes, is the T@I needs to have the status it deserves. This aligns with whatWendy Kofoed mentions in her video, that schools need to 'clear the decks' for T@I, and ensure they have, robust systems in place that support the process, that it is the main professional learning expectation for staff and that it is built into the school's staff review procedures. This is something that only Principals can address, but I may need to help them to get there. I am thinking that this is probably the best time to get them thinking about how it will be run next year. It seems so obvious to me that in order for it to be successful, staff need to see that you value it, and give time to work on it. I also realise that I need to encourage Principals to set time aside in staff meetings for reflective/critical friend meetings and help them to scaffold this.

Thursday, 10 September 2015

Supporting Inquiries

I found this video Realities of supporting teachers' inquiries (Wendy Kofoed, Educational Leaders website) really insightful and helped me to reflect on (and confirm hunches) about what is important when supporting teachers through the inquiry process.

The first point this video confirmed for me, was, that in order for Teachers' inquiries to be successful, the school leadership need to drive it. Wendy makes the following recommendations -
1. Clear the decks for action
  • Ensure school systems support teacher inquiry process. 
  • Ensure that inquiry is the main professional learning expectation for teachers. 
  • Build the expectation for participation into school performance management system. 
2. Support individual or group teacher inquiries related to acceleration goals- Support teachers to create their own inquiry action plans.
  • Support teachers to carry out inquiries. 
  • Provide opportunities for: collecting evidence of student learning: 
  • observing other teachers’ practice 
  • sharing what works /isn’t working 
  • analysing and talking about the impact of their teaching on student achievement. 
I suspected that the inquiry process wouldn't be successful if Principals left it up to me to drive it in their schools. I have since realised that the schools that are getting the most out of the process are the ones where the Principals are actively driving it. This video helps to support my suspicions. One point that Wendy makes that really stands out for me is the necessity to resource time! I have had numerous meetings with Principals around the need to make time for teachers to work on this in order to show them that it is valued. I know from my own experiences, trying to teach full time and manage all my other expectations, that Teaching as Inquiry was pushed to the side. A - because it was not driven by the top and was not part of our appraisal system, therefore it did not seem to be important to our leadership team. and B - because so little time was available for this. I know have a much stronger understanding of the value added, by undertaking an inquiry, and in hindsight I would undertake the process more rigorously than I did previously for the direct benefit to my students (I think I missed that message previously! Or I just got caught up in the everyday grind!)

I also really like the fact that she undertook the journey first (with some other teachers/leadership) so that she had an absolute understanding of what she was asking of her staff, and so she and the others, could fully support their teachers on their journey. I think this is so powerful. Principals (or leaders) who lead by example have always earned my respect over the years. I know that it is easy to dismiss, or ignore the 'do as I say, not as I do' types. However, when leaders lead by example, there is little argument. It makes the process more powerful.

I think the recommendations she gives are (obvious) but clear for Principals. It has become apparent that in order to fully support teachers with their inquiries, part of our job is to support Principals/leaders to support their teachers. This is an area I really need to develop, as I find it a little daunting to discuss leadership strategies with Principals when 9 months ago I was a Scale A teacher! So what do I really know about leadership?

What does this all mean for me? Where to next?
All this reflection has made me realise that I really need to work on how I support school leaders to lead the inquiry process. I have a number on MOE documents that I am making my way through, to find the best support material to pass on.

I also have come to the realisation, that quite a few of my schools, have not really understood why they should inquire into their actions. The questions are quite superficial, which I knew, and let go, so that they could get an understanding of the process. In hindsight, this may not have been the best course of action, as they have got a rather limited picture of what teaching as inquiry actually is. They have not researched into what they could change that might make a difference to their students.
Part of the problem here also, was that it took so long to get into teaching as inquiry in
my schools, that it was late Term 2 for some of them or even early Term 3, so they were always going to be short inquiries.

Another problem I have encountered is my lack of understanding around how to tie the inquiries into appraisal systems. I have bought this up with many of my schools, but again, since I don't have experience in this area, I was not very confident to push it. As I have thought around this issue, it seems to me, that this process is not going to be fixed in a quick meeting with me. It needs real robust kōrero, with all leaders and staff. Once again, it needs to be driven by the school for maximum effect, not me! This is another area I need to work on, developing leadership!

Wednesday, 6 May 2015

Story Hui

I love the idea of telling a story to help capture the inquiry process. If someone had used this with me when I was teaching I would have loved it. Because honestly, even though i could see the benefit of Teaching as Inquiry the sitting down and writing the evidence and reflections down was a lot to try and manage in an already busy life of being a teacher. So i did the bare minimum in order to tick it off. If someone had sat down with me and asked these probing questions I would have got a lot more out of the whole experience and probably would have thought I had done a better job in my inquiry than I did by working on it in isolation!

The concept i believe is brilliant to help us support over worked teachers who already have so much to do. I think this concept will benefit many schools and teachers. I only hope I can do it justice by trying to get schools to take it on board!

Saturday, 25 April 2015

The art of inquiry starts with listening

Book 4 of the Joan Dalton Learning talk series.

The art of inquiry starts with listening. Very important to remember this in this role. I must remember to share this with the leaders I work with, as my experience has usually been my leaders 'telling' me what my focus should be rather than one I was particularly interested in.

"While inquiry is unarguably critical to learning and our futures, developing inquirer capabilities is not as easy as it may sound" (David Anderson, 2013)